John Swinney

First Minister of Scotland and SNP leader — SNP

John Swinney
58
MODERATE
Deflector Scapegoat: Westminster

Latest Incident

Latest: What does the Milburn report mean for Scotland? - BBC — scored 8 (lucid) on 2026-11-21

Score History

Cope Entries (50)

AI-generated score

8
What does the Milburn report mean for Scotland? - BBC lucid
"Swinney says UK changes to social security and employment support could affect Scotland's budget and that Scotland must not be left worse off by Westminster decisions."

AI-generated score

42
Westminster would let Scots shiver while it controls the thermostat — Scottish National Party - SNP deflection
"Swinney argues that Westminster should relinquish control of energy policy so that the Scottish Government can act on energy bills."

AI-generated score

27
Scots invited to share their views on John Swinney plan to slash number of councils - Daily Record deflection
"John Swinney plans to force Scottish councils to merge as an SNP cost-saving measure and has pledged to reduce the number of NHS health boards to two."

AI-generated score

12
John Swinney humiliated as another flagship and expensive SNP scheme unravels - Scottish Daily Express lucid
"Swinney has said that Scotland benefits from a strong sovereign credit rating because it remains part of the United Kingdom, as he seeks to launch Scottish Government bonds."

AI-generated score

28
Youth unemployment in Scotland an 'economic catastrophe' but SNP denies there is a crisis - Daily Record deflection
"Swinney said the SNP government would take time to consider the Milburn review and its recommendations on youth unemployment."

AI-generated score

8
How is Scotland adapting to long lives? - Enlighten - Scotland's Independent Think Tank lucid
"Swinney calls the proposed consolidation of Scotland's 14 territorial NHS health boards into two the most significant structural reform of the NHS during devolution."

AI-generated score

18
Swinney’s response on oil and gas ‘is incoherent’ - The Independent deflection
"Swinney said the Scottish Government opposed the UK government's attempts to ban all new oil and gas exploration in the North Sea."

AI-generated score

30
Humiliation for John Swinney as MEPs back UK Government over Chinese wind farm factory - Scottish Daily Express deflection
"John Swinney described the UK decision to block a Chinese-owned wind-farm factory near Inverness as 'anti-Scottish' despite national-security concerns."

AI-generated score

10
Swinney criticises UK move to ban new North Sea drilling - BBC lucid
"Swinney argues that further North Sea oil and gas exploration is rational because domestic fossil fuels may have lower emissions than imported fuels and remain necessary for several years."

AI-generated score

20
Swinney ‘delighted’ as golf’s 157th Open to be hosted at Carnoustie in 2029 - The Independent deflection
"Swinney says hosting the 2029 Open at Carnoustie will provide a huge economic boost for Carnoustie, Angus, and Scotland."

AI-generated score

23
John Swinney: Why I make no apology for taking every opportunity to sell Scotland overseas - The Scotsman deflection
"Swinney argues that Scotland should aggressively promote itself overseas through education, university partnerships, trade, and investor engagement to attract students, capital, and economic opportunities."

AI-generated score

16
John Swinney confirms SNP U-turn on new North Sea oil and gas - The Scotsman deflection
"John Swinney opposes a UK government ban on new North Sea oil and gas exploration and supports assessing each development application on its merits."

AI-generated score

18
Exclusive: John Swinney says foreign trip critics 'have no understanding of selling Scotland to world' - The Scotsman deflection
"Swinney says critics of his foreign trips have no understanding of the importance of proactively selling Scotland to new and emerging markets."

AI-generated score

12
Burnham’s Budget just leaves Scots with a pickle — Scottish National Party - SNP lucid
"Swinney argues that the UK Budget undermines carbon capture in Scotland and cuts the Scottish Government's budget by around £650 million, treating Scotland as an afterthought."

AI-generated score

28
Swinney calls for ‘substantial support’ with energy bills in UK Budget - London Evening Standard deflection
"Swinney says the Chancellor's Budget would repeat Rachel Reeves's "failed budgets" if it does not provide substantial help with energy bills."

AI-generated score

28
UK, Scotland agree to explore greater autonomy despite divisions over independence - Anadolu Ajansı deflection
"Swinney says he and the prime minister agree that the Westminster system does not work for people in Scotland despite their disagreement over independence."

AI-generated score

24
Swinney calls for ‘substantial support’ with energy bills in UK Budget - NewsCord deflection
"Swinney says the Chancellor's Budget would resemble previous failed budgets if it does not provide substantial support for energy bills during the cost-of-living crisis."

AI-generated score

39
'No nation left behind' says Burnham after meeting first ministers in Glasgow - BBC deflection
"Swinney welcomed the recognition that Westminster is not working for Scotland and pledged to work constructively with Andy Burnham on devolution."

AI-generated score

18
Burnham offers to work with devolved governments to spread power to regions - London Evening Standard deflection
"Swinney says the UK Government should work constructively with the Scottish Government and ensure that devolution proposals respect Scotland's elected institutions."

AI-generated score

18
Burnham promises ‘partnership’ with devolved governments ahead of first national economic summit - Morning Star | The People’s Daily deflection
"Swinney argues that the National Economic Council gives the prime minister an opportunity to support economic growth by engaging constructively with the Scottish government's proposals."

AI-generated score

8
Scotland's Swinney raised Scotch whisky tariff concerns during India trip - Yahoo Finance UK lucid
"The attributed account says Swinney promoted Scotland's economic interests with Indian ministers and investors by discussing opportunities under the UK-India free-trade agreement."

AI-generated score

27
PM’s Scotland meeting an opportunity to ‘turn words into action’ – Swinney - www.the-independent.com deflection
"Swinney says the prime minister's meeting with Scotland should be used for the UK and Scottish governments to deliver devolution proposals."

AI-generated score

27
John Swinney calls for ‘substantial support’ with energy bills in UK Budget - Manchester Evening News deflection
"Swinney says a Budget without substantial support for energy bills would be “just like all the failed budgets” of Rachel Reeves."

AI-generated score

16
Indian polyurethane foam recycler announces plans for £6m facility in Scotland - Project Scotland deflection
"Swinney says Sarva Foam's £6 million investment and use of recycled materials can drive growth, prosperity and job creation in Scotland."

AI-generated score

18
Indian firm’s multimillion-pound investment to create 100 jobs in Scotland - Insider Media Ltd lucid
"Swinney presents Sarva Foam's planned Scottish manufacturing investment as evidence that Indian capital can stimulate growth, prosperity and job creation."

AI-generated score

18
Angry man John Swinney wants to 'pick a fight' with supermarkets over loopy SNP food cap policy - Scottish Daily Express lucid
"Swinney says rising salary costs, compounded by other expenses, squeeze the ability to invest in staff training and development, particularly at lower levels."

AI-generated score

10
Ring-fence energy fund for north-east of Scotland, says Swinney - www.lbc.co.uk lucid
"Swinney calls for North Sea revenues to be placed in a ring-fenced fund supporting the north-east of Scotland's renewables transition."

AI-generated score

15
Aberdeenshire bus passengers to benefit from £2 fare cap - Grampian Online deflection
"Swinney says expanding the £2 bus fare cap to Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire will leave passengers with more money and improve access to work, education, healthcare and leisure."

AI-generated score

31
Despite the SNP’s claims, attitudes have not shifted on S... - The Observer deflection
"Swinney claimed that political conditions are becoming increasingly favourable for Scottish independence."

AI-generated score

8
Maximising trade with India - Wired Gov lucid
"Swinney says a Scottish trade mission to India could attract significant inward investment by showcasing the country's talent, universities, and industries."

AI-generated score

18
“Golden opportunity” for Scotland’s economy as Swinney goes to India – The NEN - The NEN - North Edinburgh News deflection
"Swinney argues that closer economic and cultural ties with India and expanded Scottish exports can unlock jobs, investment and economic growth."

AI-generated score

15
Scottish First Minister urges UK Government to rejoin the EU amid £3.3bn revenue loss - Deadline News lucid
"Calls on the UK Government to rejoin the EU, stating Scotland's economic prosperity depends on it, citing an estimated £3.3bn annual revenue loss from Brexit."

AI-generated score

38
'Scotland's best future lies within the EU', John Swinney says - The National Scot deflection
"Scotland's future economic success depends on returning to EU membership as an independent nation."

AI-generated score

22
Scottish First Minister urges UK Government to rejoin the EU amid £3.3bn revenue loss - deadlinenews.co.uk lucid
"John Swinney calls for the UK to rejoin the EU as swiftly as possible, arguing Scotland's economic prosperity depends on returning to the trading bloc, citing an estimated £3.3bn revenue loss attributable to Brexit."

AI-generated score

58
No John Swinney, Scotland won’t pay for England’s social care - The Spectator deflection
"Swinney claims changes to the triple lock will cost Scottish pensioners up to £4 billion, effectively forcing them to pay for social care in England."

AI-generated score

12
Major offshore wind expansion at Port of Montrose - Wired Gov lucid
"Swinney welcomes £5m Subsea Micropiles investment in a floating offshore wind manufacturing facility at Montrose, citing Scotland's leading role in floating wind and the economic/jobs benefits of the supply chain expansion."

AI-generated score

24
Swinney backs Scotch Whisky Association call for spirits duty cut - Scottish Licensed Trade News deflection
"Swinney backs the Scotch Whisky Association's call for a cut to spirits duty in the Autumn Budget, framing whisky as a cornerstone of Scotland's economy and culture."

AI-generated score

38
Scotland's World Cup ties with Massachusetts lead to new investment push - The Herald deflection
"Scotland is globally recognised for excellence in healthcare innovation across therapeutics, diagnostics, clinical research, and digital healthcare."

AI-generated score

15
Inverclyde bus fares capped at £2 as new scheme rolled out - Greenock Telegraph deflection
"John Swinney frames a £2 bus fare cap in Inverclyde/Strathclyde as concrete government action to help households with the cost-of-living crisis by making public transport more affordable."

AI-generated score

28
£2 bus fare cap extended as Scotland moves closer to national rollout - Public Sector Executive deflection
"John Swinney frames a £2 bus fare cap as 'clear action' against the cost of living, acknowledging the challenge but offering a surface-level fare intervention rather than naming its structural drivers."

AI-generated score

58
Swinney sticks with pledge to cap prices on basic foods in Scotland - The Guardian fantasy_economics
"Swinney pledges to introduce legally binding price caps on basic foods (bread, milk, etc.) in Scotland to give families 'peace of mind' amid rising prices."

AI-generated score

38
Swinney: NHS should take the lead on social care in Scotland - communitycare.co.uk deflection
"Social care arrangements in Scotland are overly complex with competing lines of accountability, and the NHS should take the lead to improve value for money and consistency."

AI-generated score

22
Swinney’s reforms ‘too slow’ to lift business hopes - Daily Business lucid
"Swinney proposes a major projects office to speed up delivery of strategic developments and a specialist support unit for high-growth businesses to grow the economy and tackle business costs."

AI-generated score

32
Stand by for radical reform of Scotland’s public services – starting with the NHS - The Herald deflection
"Swinney's attributed position is that Scotland's £5bn fiscal gap and public service pressures should be addressed through reforming the bureaucracy of the state, applying business acumen to reshape services like the NHS."

AI-generated score

52
Industry groups call SNP food price cap plans 'unnecessary' and 'ineffective' - The Herald deflection
"Swinney announced plans to use devolved powers to compel supermarkets to cap the price of staple foods (bread, milk, cheese) in order to ease the cost of living."

AI-generated score

18
Swinney demands ‘immediate assistance’ from Westminster after energy cap rise - Perspective Media lucid
"Swinney warns the energy price cap rise will cause 'unnecessary hardship' and demands 'immediate assistance' from the UK Government for Scottish households."

AI-generated score

38
Improving lives across Scotland - Wired-Gov deflection
"Swinney claims his government has been focused on cost of living, public services, and the economy, and will deliver on its promises."

AI-generated score

44
The Herald deflection
"Swinney calls the Energy Profit Levy 'destructive' and blames the UK Government's tax regime for harming investment and jobs in the North Sea, demanding it be replaced with a 'fair tax system'."

AI-generated score

42
The Herald deflection
"The success of the Glasgow 2026 Commonwealth Games shows what Scotland can achieve when working together with ambition, and this same determination should be applied to building a stronger, fairer, more prosperous country."

AI-generated score

62
BBC Politics scapegoating
"Swinney attributed the SNP's by-election loss to the Conservatives successfully mobilising genuine regional anger over oil and gas sector policy, and said he was pushing Labour to scrap the Energy Profits Levy to help the industry."
The Cope Report
Weekly. Free. No cope.
The week's most revealing AI coverage,
scored for omission. Every Monday.
Got feedback?

Send Feedback

Custom GPT Ask the Oracle